Skip to main content

A Trip to Sleepy Hollow: Part Two

After wandering through the Sleepy Hollow Cemetery and checking out The Old Dutch Church last Friday, Amy, the girls, and I grabbed lunch at The Headless Horseman restaurant then made one more stop before heading back to Connecticut.


This humble litte abode which was built from limestone quarried from up the river at Sing Sing is Lyndhurst Castle - one of the finest examples of Gothic Revival architecture in America. The house, if you can call it a house!, is located within a 67-acre park that also contains the cast iron structure of a once beautiful conservatory (the first in the United States) as well as gardenesque landscape that was originally designed by Ferdinand Mangold who was the landscaper at Lyndhurst for 40 years.

Some of you may recognize this castle-like structure as the setting of the 1970 MGM movie, "House of Dark Shadows" which was based on the 1966-1971 gothic soap opera Dark Shadows that featured the hottest vampire around at that time - Barnabas Collins. Wait a minute here ... Barnabas Collins ... Edward Cullen ... do I detect a similarity?!? Now I'm going to have to see if I can rent the movie! Anyway ... I digress ...


Overlooking the beautiful Hudson River and Tappan Zee bridge, Lyndhurst began as a summer home on 50 acres of farm land owned by then Mayor William Paulding, Jr. of New York City. Mayor Paulding hired architect Alexander Jackson Davis, who was one of the most successful and influential American architects of his generation, to design a "small" place for he and his family to retreat to.


Originally named "Knoll", it was also known as "Paulding's Folly" because its turrets and asymmetrical outline were unlike most homes constructed in the post-colonial era. In the 19th century, though, romanticism dominated the arts and that included architecture so even though people initially criticized the design, they were still fascinated by it. It's easy to see why!

A.J. Davis completed what was to be the first phase of the home in 1842 (about the same time he designed the Wadsworth Atheneum in Hartford which is the oldest public art museum in the United States). Additionally, he designed most of the furniture which can still be seen when taking a tour of the house as when one family would move out, they would leave all of the furnishings behind.


In 1860, the house became the property of George Merritt, a New York City merchant, and it was he who hired employed the German horticulturist Ferdinand Mangold to be in charge of a permanent staff of 100 laborers to transform the then 194-acres of farmland and swamp into elaborate and more modern grounds. Merritt changed the name of the home from "Knoll" to "Lyndenhurst" after the Linden trees that were planted on the property; Merritt also brought architect Alexander Jackson Davis back in to expand the house and double it in size.


It was at that time that the new porte-cochere (portico) was designed along with a sprawling veranda that surrounds three-quarters of the house. A huge north wing was added that included an imposing four-story tower, a new dining room, two bedrooms, and servants quarters. Unfortunately, and much to our dismay, pictures are not allowed inside the castle but if you'd like to take a peek at what's in there, please click here for a virtual tour provided by the official website for Lyndhurst.


In 1880 ownership of the property, and its name, changed for the last time when it was bought by railroad magnate, Wall Street tycoon, and reported robber baron Jay Gould as a summer home for his family of six; at that time he shortened the name to "Lyndhurst". When his health was impaired by tuberculosis, the home served as a country retreat for Gould until his death in 1892. The house was then purchased by Jay Gould's oldest daughter, Helen, who bought it from her four brothers and younger sister.


Helen Gould was quite the philanthropist and when she married Finley J. Shepard, the man who pulled her from a horrible train wreck, she invited 3,000 homeless families to her wedding reception in New York City. Helen and Finley along with their three adopted children, one foster child, and two nieces lived at Lyndhurst until her death in 1938.

Following his wife's death, Finley then sold the house to Helen's younger sister, Anna - also known as the Duchess of Talleyrand-Perigord of France. Anna decorated two of the upstairs rooms to look like those in a French chateau; some of the furnishings in those rooms date back over 500 years. Talk about beautiful!


The house and grounds, including the beautiful stable above, stayed in Anna's possession until her death in 1961 when the 67-acre estate passed to the National Trust for Historic Preservation which now maintains the buildings, the grounds, and the decorative artworks that were entrusted to them.


Our tour guide, Eddie, was very knowledgeable and you could tell that he really loved his job of telling visitors about Lyndhurst and the families that lived there. In particular he seemed quite in awe of Helen Goulding and when he spoke of her it reminded me very much of when Mr. Collins would speak of Lady Catherine de Bourgh in Pride and Prejudice! Still, she did sound to be a wonderful woman who was way ahead of her time and she seemed to have no problems in sharing the vast fortune that her father had amassed with those less fortunate. Truly a woman to be admired.


One of the main things that we all found fascinating during our tour was the fact that inside the house there were a lot of faux finishes. Apparently during that time, it was quite fashionable for architects to use paint to turn plain pine into heavy wooden beams as well as marble pillars and other stonework. The only 'real' marble used inside the house was on the fireplaces but you would never have been able to tell that if your tour guide didn't tell you ahead of time. It was really quite ingenious and made the tour even that much more interesting. I really wish I had pictures to show you!


To be honest, when I first thought about visiting Lyndhurst, I wasn't too sure how enthusiastic the girls were going to be about touring an old house but it turned out that they both really enjoyed it and found it quite fascinating (maybe there's a tiny bit of my love of history in them after all??). Their only regret was in not being able to take pictures inside!

Gee, seeing that they liked this old house, perhaps I shall have to take them to the mansions in Newport at some point after all!

Popular posts from this blog

The Tale of Indian Leap at Yantic Falls in Norwich

Long before English settlers purchased the 9-mile square of land upon which the City of Norwich, Connecticut sits, the land was owned and occupied by the Mohegan Tribe of Indians. They made their homes near the Great Falls of the City of Kings and were led by the great sachem, Uncas.

One of the more popular and famous stories of Chief Uncas involves The Battle of the Great Plain that took place on September 17th, 1643 between the Mohegan Tribe and the Narragansett Tribe from neighboring Rhode Island, some of which took place near what is now known as "Indian Leap".

As the story goes, Miantonomo, Sachem of the Narragansetts, led 900 of his warriors in what was to be a surprise attack on the Mohegans at Shetucket, the Mohegan capital near the City of Kings. The night before the battle, Mohegan scouts in the area observed the advancing enemy and carried the intelligence back to Uncas who formed a plan.

Uncas knew he didn't have enough warriors to battle Miantonomo but he…

Triple-Sheeting Defined

In a recent post on the beautiful Inn Victoria in Chester, Vermont, I mentioned "triple-sheeting" and a commenter asked, "What's triple sheeting? Is that the same as being 3 sheets to the wind??" Uhm, no, Sarah, it isn't! Though I can certainly appreciate the humor in your comment!

Triple-sheeting, a style of bed-making that uses multiple layers of sheets, blankets, and duvets or bedspread-like covers, is something that a lot of upscale hotels, inns, and bed and breakfasts are starting to do as it's not only an easy way to change the design of the room should that be desired but it's also a lot more hygienic for guests.

If you stop and think about it, chances are really good that the bedspreads and/or duvets that are used in guest accommodations don't get washed very often and they most definitely don't get washed in between every guest.  Think about how often you wash your own bedspread and the light probably goes on, right?  Uh-huh ... Do…

A Virtual Visit to Salem's House of the Seven Gables - Part Two, The Turner-Ingersoll Mansion

"Halfway down a by-street of one of our New England towns stands a rusty wooden house, with seven acutely peaked gables, facing towards various points of the compass, and a huge, clustered chimney in the midst. The street is Pyncheon Street; the house is the old Pyncheon House; and an elm-tree, of wide circumference, rooted before the door, is familiar to every town-born child by the title of the Pyncheon Elm." - Chapter One, The House of the Seven Gables by Nathaniel Hawthorne, 1851
Whether he meant it to or not, the dwelling that took on the life of the "rusty wooden house" in Hawthorne's second novel, and which became popularly known as The House of the Seven Gables, began its story in 1668 as the house of a prominent Salem resident before almost 240 years later taking on the role of a social reform-based settlement house and museum.

John Turner, the son of an English-born shoemaker and hat merchant of Boston who died when Turner was seven, moved to the No…